China Technology Licensing: The Questions We Ask

My law firm’s international licensing lawyers have been writing a slew of China technology licensing agreements lately. These deals usually come to us as China licensing deals. Sometimes they come to us as putative joint ventures, but after we explain the difficulties and costs in doing a joint venture, our clients seek to restructure their relationship with their Chinese counter-party into a licensing arrangement.

The licensing deals our lawyers have been handling in the last couple years often involve Chinese companies that seek to license the technology from our American or European clients as a stepping-stone to building their own cheaper products in China, then later using the funds they receive from their new product sales to further develop and refine (and perhaps even localize) the technology and their own products. Sometimes the deals are with Chinese companies that want to put the technology to immediate use to improve on existing products they sell in China.

The below is a list of initial questions I pulled from an email from one of our China licensing lawyers to a client based on the licensing term sheet to which the client and the potential Chinese company licensee had signed off. The email posed some initial questions, the answers to which were necessary to allow this lawyer to being drafting the licensing agreement.

1. Territory

a. For “China,” does this include Taiwan? Hong Kong?  Macao? These three jurisdictions all have an independent patent/trademark system. We do not use the term “China” in our agreements since it is not clear. We use the term PRC to refer only to Mainland China. To which of these countries were you referring?

b. The term “Southeast Asia” has no precise meaning. Please identify the specific countries intended to be included. In particular, what is the status of Singapore, Indonesia, Malaysia, and The Philippines?

2. Note with respect to Territory. There are a number of separate issues:

a. Place of manufacture.

b. Place where patents/trademarks must be maintained.

c. Place where sales are permitted.

The three are quite distinct and it will be important we be clear on all three. It seems to me you are proposing the following:

a. Territory of manufacture is the PRC.

b. Territory of patents is PRC, Republic of Korea, Hong Kong and Japan.

c. Territory of sales is PRC, Republic of Korea, Japan, Taiwan, Hong Kong, Macao, Viet Nam, Thailand, Cambodia, Laos, Malaysia, Indonesia, Singapore and The Philippines.

Please advise on whether the above is correct? If yes, this will require some complex drafting, but it is doable.

3. Your statement of the license grant is a typical U.S. grant, which includes the right to sublicense. We though generally advise against giving the Chinese licensee the ability to sublicense. What is you position on this?

4. For a manufacturing license, we prefer to see our clients limit the Chinese side to manufacturing only in the PRC at a manufacturing facility you (the licensor) have approved in advance. Do you agree with this?

5. This agreement is for two products. How do you want to deal with the trademarks and logos for both of these products? Will the patent license also include the associated trademarks and logos? What is the current registration status of registration of those marks in the applicable territories? You controlling the trademarks is a powerful way for you to control the right to manufacture and sell the products, and if you have not registered your trademarks in the PRC and in the other countries in which your licensee will be operating, you should consider such registrations in connection with this project. Let’s discuss this.

6. In your Performance Metrics section, you raise the important issue of the Chinese company’s obligation to pursue approvals in the appropriate territories and to sell the two products in those territories. This is extremely complex. To list out just some of the issues:

a. What is the obligation of the Chinese company to apply for and receive approval with respect to each of the countries in which you will be granting it the licenses? What happens if the Chinese company receives approval in the PRC, but does not even try to secure approval in the other territories? What happens if the Chinese company receives approval for Korea, but not for the PRC? How are you intending for this to all work?

b. Is the stated sales goal just for the PRC or for the entire sales territory? Have you considered separate sales goals for each country?

c. What is the penalty to the Chinese company if it does not achieve the performance metric. For example, what if they don’t even try for Korea? We could draft it so that you can either terminate the entire license or simply remove Korea from the territory. If the sales goal is cumulative, then you would terminate the entire license. But if the sales goal is by country, then you would remove the country from the license.

7. In the performance metrics, you properly make clear that actively pursuing approval for sale is required for the license and you provide a hard deadline for one product. But since there are two products and as many as fifteen different countries, this could get impossibly complex. We will need to provide a manageable way to keep track of two separate issues for each product and for each country: the approvals to sell and the actual sales,. The simplest way for us to do this is to set an overall gross sales goal, without any specification of country of sales. If the sales goal is met, that’s the end of it. Then you can provide that if no approval is obtained for a particular region by a particular time for a particular product, you have the right to remove that country from the sales territory for that product. It seems this approach will work best but I would like to hear your thoughts on this.

8. It seems the buy back right for manufacture should only apply if the Chinese company meets all its obligations under the license. Do you agree?

Please consider the above and provide me with your comments and questions.

For more on what goes into a China licensing contract, check out: